Rent or buy: what each one really costs
Enter your numbers. This shows what renting and buying cost each month, and which one leaves you ahead after the years you plan to stay. Everything runs in your browser, and nothing is saved or sent anywhere.
Result
- Buying, first month
- Renting, first month
- Money you pay upfront to buy
- Break-even home price growth
Net worth over time
| Year | Buying | Renting | Ahead |
|---|
Net worth = savings you invested, plus your home equity after selling costs for buying. Renting counts only the savings you invested. Tax benefits such as the mortgage interest deduction are not included, so check them for your situation.
How this is worked out
Each month, the buying path pays the mortgage payment (principal and interest), property tax, home insurance and upkeep. The renting path pays rent and renter insurance. Rent grows at your rent-growth rate. Taxes, insurance and upkeep grow at the inflation rate.
Buying also pays the down payment and closing costs at the start. Renting keeps that money and invests it. Each month, whichever path costs less invests the difference at the return you enter. At the end, buying counts your home at its estimated value, minus selling costs and the mortgage balance still owed. The break-even figure is the home price growth at which the two paths leave you exactly even.
What this does not include
- Tax deductions for mortgage interest or property tax, or any tax on investment gains.
- Private mortgage insurance, HOA fees, moving costs, or the cost of time spent on repairs.
- Changes in interest rates, which can only be modeled by changing the rate yourself.
Sources
- The mortgage payment uses the standard fixed-rate formula, and the balance uses the same formula for the remaining payments. The calculations are checked against independent computations in the project's tests.
- The default numbers are examples chosen to be realistic, not market data. Check your own quotes, tax bill and insurance estimate before deciding.
This is education, not financial, tax or legal advice. Talk with a licensed professional before a housing decision.